| 1st | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Spotted Owls | | Spotted Owls | Miles Mikolas | P | Cards | |
| Grays | | Grays | Joey Bart | C | Giants | 1 |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Jeff McNeill | Inf | NYM | |
| FreeBasers | | Shark Bites | Jesus Agular | 1B | Mil | |
| Shamrogs | | Midnight Venom | Max Muncy | 2nd | LAD | |
| Century Sprockets | | Los Ingobernables | Jose Leclerc | RHP | Tex | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Volunteers | Jesus Luzardo | LHP | Oak | 2 |
| Guerillas | | Volunteers | Alex Kirilloff | OF | Min | 3 |
| Sans Culottes | | Midnight Venom | Seranonthy Dominguez | RHP | Phil | |
| Midnight Venom | | Heartbreakers | Ryan Yarbough | LHP | TB | |
| Howlin' Wolves | | Howlin' Wolves | Joey Jimmeniz | P | Det | |
| Shark Bites | | Ikrans | Nick Pivetta | P | Phil | |
| BaseBall Furies | | Los Ingobernables | Dereck Rodriguez | P | SF | |
| Rottweilers | | Rottweilers | Casey Mize | P | Det | 4 |
| Fighting Skunks | | Fighting Skunks | Corbun Burnes | P | Mil | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Heartbreakers | Marco Gonzalez | P | Sea | |
| Swingers | | Volunteers | Isssiah Kiner-Falefa | C-Inf | Tex | |
| Ikrans | | Shark Bites | Brad Keller | P | KC | |
| Heartbreakers | | Heartbreakers | John Gant | P | Stl | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Kirtby Yates | P | SD | |
| 12:20 | | | | | | |
| 2nd | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Shark Bites | Annibal Sanchez | P | Atl | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Howlin' Wolves | Jordan Hicks | P | Stl | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Troglodytes | Adam Ottavino | P | Col | |
| Sans Culottes | | Volunteers | Branden Lowe | 2B | TB | |
| Guerillas | | Midnight Venom | Joey Lucchesi | P | SD | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Swingers | Joey Wendel | 2B | TB | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | Nathan Eovaldi | P | Bos | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Ikrans | Shane Carle | P | Atl | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Adley Rutschman | C | Oregon State | 5 |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Jose Castillo | P | SD | |
| Grays | even | FreeBasers | Willans Astudilo | C | Min | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | Diego Castillo | P | TB | |
| Rottweilers | 1ST | Rottweilers | Jamie Barria | P | LAA | |
| BaseBall Furies | 2ND | BaseBall Furies | Yony Chirinos | P | TB | |
| Fighting Skunks | 3RD | Fighting Skunks | Nick Madrigal | 2B | ChiW | 6 |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | BaseBall Furies | Chad Pinder | Utl | Oak | |
| Swingers | | Swingers | Ramon Laureano | CF | OF | |
| Ikrans | | Ikrans | Victor Arano | P | Phil | |
| Heartbreakers | | Swingers | Shane Bieber | P | Clev | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Reyes Moronta | P | | |
| | 12:45 | | | | | |
| 3rd | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Fighting Skunks | Lou Trevino | P | SD | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | BaseBall Furies | Franchy Cordero | OF | SD | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Howlin' Wolves | Coby Jones | OF | Det | |
| Sans Culottes | | Swingers | Will Smith | P | SF | |
| Guerillas | | Volunteers | Vidal Brujan | 2B | TB | 7 |
| Los Ingobernables | | Fighting Skunks | Josh James | P | Hou | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | Freddy Peralta | P | Mil | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Grayson Griener | C | Det | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Ikrans | Lou Voit | 1B | NYY | |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Yordan Alvarez | 1B | Hou | 8 |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | Ryne Stanek | P | TB | |
| Grays | even | Grays | David Bowdie | Utl | ChiC | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | BaseBall Furies | Carter Kieboom | 2B | Was | 9 |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Fighting Skunks | Chris Paddack | P | SD | 10 |
| Rottweilers | R | Rottweilers | Yoshi Hirano | P | Arz | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Ikrans | Dylan Cease | P | ChiW | 11 |
| Swingers | | Swingers | Jonathan Holder | P | NYY | |
| Ikrans | | Fighting Skunks | Caleb Fergusion | P | LAD | |
| Heartbreakers | | Midnight Venom | Mitch Garver | C | Min | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Ryan Brasier | P | Bos | |
| | | | | | | |
| 1:06 | | | | | | |
| 4th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Ikrans | Jazz Chisolm | SS | SD | 12 |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Howlin' Wolves | AJ Minter | P | Atl | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Swingers | Richard Rodriquez | P | Pits | |
| Sans Culottes | | Sans Culottes | Garret Hampson | Inf | Col | 13 |
| Guerillas | | Troglodytes | Oliver Perez | P | Clev | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Swingers | Franmil Reyes | OF | SD | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | Steve Duggar | OF | SF | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Spotted Owls | Yusei Kikuchi | P | Sea | 14 |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Dylan Cobey | P | ChiW | |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Jace Fry | P | ChiW | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Robbie Erlin | P | SD | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | Edgar Santana | P | Pitt | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Century Sprockets | Framber Valdez | P | Hou | |
| Rottweilers | R | Rottweilers | Nolan Gorman | 3B | Stl | 15 |
| BaseBall Furies | B | BaseBall Furies | Dakota Hudson | P | Stl | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Mackinaw Maniacs | Wade Leblanc | P | SD | |
| Swingers | | Howlin' Wolves | Nico Godrum | 1B | Det | |
| Ikrans | | Howlin' Wolves | Daz Cameron | OF | Det | 16 |
| Heartbreakers | | Sans Culottes | Bobby Witt Jr | SS | HS | 17 |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Taylor Cole | P | LAA | |
| 1:30 | | | | | | |
| 5th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Midnight Venom | Curt Cassila | C | Cin | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Grays | Dan Poncedeleon | P | Stl | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Sans Culottes | Jared Kelenic | OF | Sea | 18 |
| Sans Culottes | | Sans Culottes | Fernando Romero | P | Min | |
| Guerillas | | Spotted Owls | Chris Bassitt | P | Oak | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Spotted Owls | Ryan Lemarre | OF | Stl | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | Pete Alonso | 1B | NYM | 19 |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Tyer Mahle | P | Cin | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Spotted Owls | Steve Pearce | 1B | Bos | |
| Volunteers | | Mackinaw Maniacs | Shawn Kelly | P | Oal | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | Blaine Hardy | P | Det | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Clay Bucholtz | P | Arz | |
| Rottweilers | R | Ikrans | Justus Sheffeild | P | Sea | 20 |
| BaseBall Furies | B | Midnight Venom | Ryan Borucki | P | Tor | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Fighting Skunks | Scott Oberg | P | Col | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Mackinaw Maniacs | Roanis Elias | P | Sea | |
| Swingers | | Grays | Jose Briceno | C | LAA | |
| Ikrans | | Shark Bites | Billy Mckenny | OF | Tor | |
| Heartbreakers | | Troglodytes | Jonathan India | 3B | Cin | 21 |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Nick Martini | OF | Oak | |
| 2:00 | | | | | | |
| 6th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Rottweilers | Andrew Suarez | P | SF | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Howlin' Wolves | Oneil Cruz | SS | Pit | 22 |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Sans Culottes | Shea Langeliers | C | Baylor | 23 |
| Sans Culottes | | Sans Culottes | Griffin Canning | P | LAA | 24 |
| Guerillas | | Sans Culottes | Jonathan Loasigia | P | NYY | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Los Ingobernables | Marcus Semen | SS | Oak | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | David Fletcher | 2B | LAA | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | zShark Bites | | | | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Volunteers | Trevor May | P | Min | |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Roman Quinn | OF | Phil | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Domingo German | P | NYY | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | Max Stassi | C | Hou | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | BaseBall Furies | Luke Maile | C | Tor | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Fighting Skunks | Edwin Jackson | P | Oak | |
| Rottweilers | R | Troglodytes | Michael Perez | C | TB | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Mackinaw Maniacs | Matt Kemp | OF | LAD | |
| Swingers | | Heartbreakers | Yairo Munoz | SS | Stl | |
| Ikrans | | Spotted Owls | Paul Fry | P | Balt | |
| Heartbreakers | | Wolves (from trade) | Seann Murphy | C | Oak | 25 |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Tony Barnette | P | Tex | |
| 2:21 | | | | | | |
| 7th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Mackinaw Maniacs | Jessie Biddle | P | Alt | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Mackinaw Maniacs | Javier Cedeno | P | Mil | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Sans Culottes | Dustin May | P | LAD | 26 |
| Sans Culottes | | Guerillas | Phil Ervin | OF | Cin | |
| Guerillas | | Grays | Tony Kemp | OF | Hou | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Guerillas | Ronald Guzman | 1B | Tex | |
| Century Sprockets | | Century Sprockets | Caleb Smith | P | Mia | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Sam Gaviglio | P | Tor | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Guerillas | Andrew Vaughn | 1B | CalBerkley | 27 |
| Volunteers | | Guerillas | Mark Canha | OF | OA | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | BaseBall Furies | Christain Pache | OF | Atl | 28 |
| Grays | even | Mackinaw Maniacs | Jake Cave | OF | Min | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Fighting Skunks | Ryan Ohern | 1B | KC | |
| Rottweilers | R | Rottweilers | Kevin McCarthy | P | KC | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | BaseBall Furies | Felix Pena | P | LAA | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Los Ingobernables | Miguel Mamaya | C | Chic | 29 |
| Swingers | | Swingers | Austin Pruitt | P | TB | |
| Ikrans | | FreeBasers | Rowdy Toltez | 1B | Tor | |
| Heartbreakers | | zHeartbreakers | | | | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Austin Davis | P | Phil | |
| 2:41 | | | | | | |
| 8th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Fighting Skunks | Lourdes Goreal | SS | Tor | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Howlin' Wolves | Yusniel Diaz | OF | Balt | 30 |
| Midnight Venom | odd | Spotted Owls | Robbie Grossman | OF | Min | |
| Sans Culottes | | Spotted Owls | Chaz Roe | P | TB | |
| Guerillas | | Fighting Skunks | Daniel Desclaso | OF | Arz | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Los Ingobernables | Amir Garret | P | Cin | |
| Century Sprockets | | zCentury Sprockets | | | | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Fighting Skunks | Victor Alcantarez | P | Det | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Drew Verhagen | P | Det | |
| Volunteers | | Spotted Owls | Richard Urena | 2b | Tor | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Jordan Lyles | P | Mil | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | Spotted Owls | David Hess | P | Balt | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | Fighting Skunks | Spencer Kieboom | C | Was | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | zBaseBall Furies | | | | |
| Rottweilers | R | Rottweilers | Austin Wynns | C | Balt | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | Los Ingobernables | Isaac Perades | SS | Det | 31 |
| Swingers | | Swingers | Steve Brault | P | Balt | |
| Ikrans | | zIkrans | | | | |
| Heartbreakers | | zHeartbreakers | | | | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Andres Gimenez | SA | NYM | 32 |
| | | | | | | |
| 2:55 | | | | | | |
| 9th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | Troglodytes | Will Smith | C | LAD | 33 |
| Midnight Venom | odd | zMidnight Venom | | | | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | Troglodytes | Gavin Lux | SS | LAD | 34 |
| Sans Culottes | | Guerillas | Ehire Adrianza | Utl | Min | |
| Guerillas | | zSpotted Owls | | | | |
| Los Ingobernables | | Guerillas | Ronaldo Hernadez | C | TB | 35 |
| Century Sprockets | | zCentury Sprockets | | | | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Trevor Richards | P | Mia | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | Los Ingobernables | Austin Romine | C | NYY | |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Justine Anderson | P | LAA | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | zSpotted Owls | | | | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Brian Johnson | P | Bos | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | zFighting Skunks | | | | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | zBaseBall Furies | | | | |
| Rottweilers | R | zRottweilers | | | | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | zMackinaw Maniacs | | | | |
| Swingers | | Swingers | Dylan Floro | P | LAD | |
| Ikrans | | zIkrans | | | | |
| Heartbreakers | | zHeartbreakers | | | | |
| Troglodytes | | Troglodytes | Lewis Garcia | SS | Was | 36 |
| 3:05 | | | | | | |
| 10th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | zShark Bites | | | | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | SB (trade) | Daniel Winkler | P | At | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | zMidnight Venom | | | | |
| Sans Culottes | | Guerillas | Lewis Coleman | P | Det | |
| Guerillas | G | Guerillas | Alex Blandino | Utl | Cin | |
| Los Ingobernables | L | Los Ingobernables | Jorge Soler | OF | KC | |
| Century Sprockets | | zCentury Sprockets | | | | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | Shamrogs | Josh Harrison | 2B | Pit | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | FreeBasers | MJ Melendez | C | KC | 37 |
| Volunteers | | Volunteers | Robert Stock | P | SD | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Matt Grace | P | Was0 | |
| Spotted Owls | odd | zSpotted Owls | | | | |
| Fighting Skunks | F | zFighting Skunks | | | | |
| BaseBall Furies | B | zBaseBall Furies | | | | |
| Rottweilers | R | zRottweilers | | | | |
| Mackinaw Maniacs | | zMackinaw Maniacs | | | | |
| Swingers | | zSwingers | | | | |
| Ikrans | | zIkrans | | | | |
| Heartbreakers | | zHeartbreakers | | | | |
| Troglodytes | | zTroglodytes | | | | |
| 3:15 | | | | | | |
| 11th | Ties | Drafting Team | Player | Team | Pos | no-card |
| Shark Bites | | zShark Bites | | | | |
| Midnight Venom | odd | zMidnight Venom | | | | |
| Howlin' Wolves | even | zShark Bites | | | | |
| Sans Culottes | | zSans Culottes | | | | |
| Guerillas | L | Los Ingobernables | Shawn Reid Foley | P | Tor | |
| Los Ingobernables | G | zGuerillas | | | | |
| Century Sprockets | | zCentury Sprockets | | | | |
| Shamrogs | ODD | zShamrogs | | | | |
| FreeBasers | EVEN | FreeBasers | William Conteras | C | Atl | 38 |
| Volunteers | | zVolunteers | | | | |
| Spotted Owls | oddd | zSpotted Owls | | | | |
| Grays | even | Grays | Cedric Mullins | OF | Balt | |
| | | Grays | Pablo Reyes | OF | Pit | |
| | | Grays | Noah RAMERIZ | P | LAA | |
| 3:30 | | | | | | |
