| 1 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | pos | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Freebasers | Yan Gomes | Clev | C | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Detroit Dawgz | Tony Cingrani | Cin | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | BaseBall Furies | Kris Bryant | ChC | 3B | 1 |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Midnight Venom | Leonys Martin | Tex | OF | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Spotted Owls | Danny Salazar | Clev | P | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Volunteers | Masahiro Tanaka | NYY | P | 2 |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Volunteers | Ryan Gennett | Mil | 2B | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Crawdads | Yoronda Ventura | KC | P | |
| 9 | Reelists | Reelists | Jon Gray | Col | P | 3 |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Nine Unknown Men | AJ Pollock | Arz | OF | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Crawdads | Robert Stephenson | Cin | P | 4 |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Detroit Dawgz | Tyson Ross | SD | P | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Eddie Butler | Col | P | 5 |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Brad Miller | Cin | SS | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Rottweilers | Marlon Byrd | Phi | OF | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Odontoblasts | Alex Wood | Atl | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | BaseBall Furies | Chris Owings | Arz | SS | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz | Jody Mercer | Pit | SS | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Crawdads | Blake Swihart | Bo | C | 6 |
| 20 | Crawdads | Guerillas | Bryan Dozer | Min | 2B | |
| | | | | | | |
| 2 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Troglodytes | Carlos Rodon | NC St | P | 7 |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Kevin Siegrist | Stl | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Cody Asche | Phil | 3b | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Reelists (ree) | Marcelo Ozuna | Mia | OF | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Crawdads (gue) | James Paxton | Sea | P | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Spotted Owls (spo) | Tyler Chatwood | Col | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Howlin' Wolves (sha) | Garret Richards | LAA | P | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Volunteers (vol) | Dioneer Navarro | Tor | C | |
| 9 | Reelists | Midnight Venom | Matt Davidson | ChW | 3B | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Howlin' Wolves (how) | Tyle Thornburg | Mil | P | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Tanner Roark | Was | P | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Fighting Skunks | Caleb Thielbar | Min | P | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Kyle Crick | SD | P | 8 |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Kris Davis | Mil | OF | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Odontoblasts (odo) | David Carpenter | Atl | P | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Troglodytes (rot) | Ryan Rayburn | Clev | OF | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Lucas Sims | Atl | P | 9 |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | Jr Lake | OF | Cubs | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | Josmil Pinto | C | Min | |
| 20 | Crawdads | BaseBall Furies | Cory Kluber | Clev | P | |
| | | | | | | |
| 3 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Shark Bites | Jenmar Gomez | Pit | P | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Detroit Dawgz | Alex Torres | TB | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Crawdads (ree) | Jon Villar | Hou | SS | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | John Lakey | Bos | P | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Guerillas (gue) | Juan Lagares | NYM | OF | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Crawdads (sha) | Joc Pederson | LAD | OF | 10 |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Volunteers (vol) | Julio Urias | LAD | P | 11 |
| 8 | Guerillas | Spotted Owls (spo) | Arron Loup | Tor | P | |
| 9 | Reelists | BaseBall Furies | Jose Abreau | ChiW | 1B | 12 |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Fighting Skunks (how) | Eric Sogard | Oak | 2B | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Kole Calhoun | LAA | OF | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Reelists | Evan Gattis | Atl | C | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Tom Koehler | Mia | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Danny Farquha | Sea | P | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Rottweilers (rot) | Brandon Kintzler | Mil | P | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Shark Bites (odo) | Paco Rodriguez | LAD | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Dominic Smith | NYM | 1B | 13 |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Crawdads (det) | Matt Wiesler | SD | P | 14 |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | BaseBall Furies | Scott Kazmir | Oak | P | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Detroit Dawgz | JJ Hoover | Cin | P | |
| 4 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Troglodytes | Nick Vincent | SD | P | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Neil Cotts | Tex | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Vince Mazzaro | Pit | P | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Volunteers (ree) | Justin Wilson | Pit | P | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Detroit Dawgz (gue) | JB Shuck | LAA | OF | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Volunteers (vol) | Danny Duffy | KC | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Nine Unknown Men (spo) | Nick Tepesch | Tex | P | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Shamrogs (sha) | Jake Diekman | Phil | P | |
| 9 | Reelists | Reelists | Clint Frazier | Clev | OF | 15 |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Shark Bites (how) | Charles Morton | Pit | P | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Erik Johnson | ChiW | P | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Midnight Venom | James Loney | TB | 1B | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Brett Oberholtzer | Hou | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | JP Howell | LAD | P | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | SharkBites (odo) | Jesse Chavez | Oak | P | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Volunteers (rot) | Reese McGuire | Pit | C | 16 |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Charlie Blackmon | Col | Of | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Shark Bites (det) | Latroy Hawkins | Col | P | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | Roughned Odor | Tex | 2B | 17 |
| 20 | Crawdads | Troglodytes | Cody Allen | Clev | P | |
| 5 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Hearse Riders | Mike Carp | Bos | 1B | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Brandon Barnes | Hou | OF | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Reelists (ree) | AJ Ramos | Mia | P | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Connor Gilespie | ChiW | 3B | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Spotted Owls (gue) | Alfredo Simon | Cin | P | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Midnight Venom (spo) | Jim Henderson | Mil | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Grays (sha) | Seth Maness | Stl | P | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Howlin' Wolves (vol) | Jorge Alfaro | Tex | C | 18 |
| 9 | Reelists | Howlin'Wolves | Jarod Cozart | Hou | P | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Howlin' Wolves (how) | Jesse WInker | Cin | OF | 19 |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Steve Vogt | Oak | C | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Troglodytes | Chris Withrow | LAD | P | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Louis Coleman | KC | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Guerillas | Norbis Medina | Sea | P | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Rottweilers (rot) | Dan Otero | Oak | P | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Odontoblasts (odo) | Josh Fields | Hou | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Roberto Herndez | TB | P | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | Giovanni Soto | Stl | C | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | Juan Uribe | LAD | 3B | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Volunteers | Bruce Compton | Pit | P | |
| 6 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Troglodytes | Jeff Baker | Tex | 1B | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Marcus Semien | ChiW | 2B | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Rafeal Montero | NYM | P | 20 |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Reelists (ree) | Miakel Franco | Phil | 3B | 21 |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Guerillas (gue) | Mike Dunn | Mia | P | |
| 6 | Volunteers | | | | | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Fighting Skunks (vol) | Ethan Martin | Phil | P | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Spotted Owls (spo) | Andrew Albers | Min | P | |
| 9 | Reelists | BaseBall Furies | Wil Nieves | Arz | C | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Howlin' Wolves (how) | Ed Lucas | Mia | 2B | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Rottweilers (mid) | Tyler Lyons | Stl | P | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Midnight Venom | Ryan Goins | Tor | 2B | |
| 13 | Grays | Shamrogs | James McCann | Det | C | 22 |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Dean Ruff | Phil | 1B | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Odontoblasts (odo) | Cesar Hernandez | Phil | 2B | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Rottweilers (rot) | Josh Phegley | ChW | C | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Ross Ohlendorf | Was | P | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | Pedro Florimon | Min | SS | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Reelists (fig) | Dan Delarosa | LAA | P | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Troglodytes | Marus Storman | Tor | P | 23 |
| 7 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | BaseBall Furies | Eric O'Flaherty | Atl | P | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Kohl Stewart | Min | P | 24 |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Clowns (ree) | Michael Choice | Oak | OF | 25 |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Ryan Flaherty | Bal | 2B | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | OdontoBlasts (gue) | Alfredo Gonzalez | Phil | P | 26 |
| 6 | Volunteers | Midnight Venom (vol) | Jon Pettibone | TB | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Spotted Owls (spo) | Carlos Torres | NYM | P | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Howlin' Wolves (sha) | Derek Dietrich | Mia | 2B | |
| 9 | Reelists | Troglodytes | Donny Murphy | ChiC | 1B | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Odontoblasts (how) | Andrew Heaney | Mia | P | 27 |
| 11 | Troglodytes | BaseBall Furies (mid) | Tim Federowicz | LAD | C | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Spotted Owls | Jason Nyx | NYY | OF | |
| 13 | Grays | Howlin' Wolves | Matt Albers | Clev | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Jean Machi | SF | P | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Clowns (rot) | Eduardo Escobar | Min | 2B | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Howlin' Wolves (odo) | Chad Gaudin | SF | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Todd Redmond | Tor | P | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | CJ Edwards | ChiC | P | 28 |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Spotted Owls (fig) | Ryan Presley | Min | P | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Spotted Owls | LJ Hoes | Hou | OF | |
| 8 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Guerillas | Anthony Varvaro | Alt | P | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | Trea Turner | NC St | SS | 29 |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Allen Webster | Bos | P | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Midnight Venom (ree) | Abraham Almonte | Sea | OF | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Hearse Riders (gue) | Austin Meadows | Pit | OF | 30 |
| 6 | Volunteers | Hearse Riders (spo) | Adam Warren | NYY | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Howlin' Wolves (sha) | Kyle Parker | Col | 1B | 31 |
| 8 | Guerillas | Volunteers (vol) | Rymal Tapia | Col | OF | 32 |
| 9 | Reelists | Midnight Venom | Colin Moran | Mia | 3B | 33 |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Howlin' Wolves (how) | Mike Foltynewicz | Hou | P | 34 |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Rottweilers (mid) | Tyler Glasnow | Pit | Pit | 35 |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Spotted Owls | Cesar Ramos | TB | P | |
| 13 | Grays | Howlin' Wolves | Jeff Locke | Pit | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Chad Qualls | Mia | P | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Guerillas (odo) | Dallas Keuchel | Hou | P | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Spotted Owls (rot) | Ryan Webb | Mia | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | Spotted Owls | Blake Parker | Chn | P | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | | | | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | Braden Shippley | SD | P | 36 |
| 20 | Crawdads | Reelists | Henry Owens | Bos | P | 37 |
| 9 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Shark Bites | Andrew Susca | SF | C | 38 |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Reelists | Javier Lopez | SD | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Reelists (ree) | Don Kelly | Det | OF | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | Corey Dickerson | Col | OF | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Guerillas (gue) | David Lough | KC | OF | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Crawdads | Jorge Delrosa | Col | P | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Volunteers (vol) | | | | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Spotted Owls (spo) | Muninaro Kawasaki | Tor | SS | |
| 9 | Reelists | Reelists | Brandon Workman | Bos | P | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Howlin' Wolves (how) | | | | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Drake Britton | Bos | P | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Reelists | Derick Jeter | NYY | SS | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | Kevin Gregg | ChC | P | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Danny Valencia | Bat | 3B | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Rottweilers (rot) | Hunter Renfroe | SD | OF | 39 |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Guerillas (odo) | Andrew Romine | LAA | 2B | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | Brandon Mauer | Sea | P | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | | | | | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | Derick Robinson | Cin | OF | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Spotted Owls | George Kottaras | KC | C | |
| 10 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | | | | | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Reelists | Luis Mendoza | KC | P | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | | | | | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Reelists (ree) | Jerome Williams | LAA | P | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Guerillas (gue) | Alfredo Figero | Mil | P | |
| 6 | Volunteers | | | | | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | | | | | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Hearse Riders (sha) | Michael Morse | SF | 1B | |
| 9 | Reelists | | | | | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | | | | | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | Josh Willingham | Min | OF | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | | | | | |
| 13 | Grays | | | | | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | Hearse Riders | Jake Barrett | Arz | P | 40 |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | | | | | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Rottweilers (rot) | Wil Harris | Arz | P | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | | | | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | | | | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | | | | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Crawdads | | | | |
| 11 | Original Team | Drafting Team | Player | MLB Team | P | No-card |
| 1 | FreeBasers | Shark Bites | | | | |
| 2 | Howlin' Wolves | Troglodytes | | | | |
| 3 | BaseBall Furies | Nine Unknown Men (nin) | | | | |
| 4 | Midnight Venom | Reelists (ree) | | | | |
| 5 | Spotted Owls | Guerillas (gue) | Tony Cruz | Stl | C | |
| 6 | Volunteers | Spotted Owls (spo) | | | | |
| 7 | Shamrogs | Shamrogs (sha) | | | | |
| 8 | Guerillas | Volunteers (vol) | | | | |
| 9 | Reelists | BaseBall Furies | | | | |
| 10 | Nine Unknown Men | Guerillas (how) | | | | |
| 11 | Troglodytes | Midnight Venom (mid) | | | | |
| 12 | Shark Bites | Freebasers | | | | |
| 13 | Grays | Grays | | | | |
| 14 | Hearse Riders | | | | | |
| 15 | Rottweilers (odd) | Odontoblasts (odo) | | | | |
| 16 | Odontoblasts (even) | Rottweilers (rot) | | | | |
| 17 | Clowns | Clowns | | | | |
| 18 | Detroit Dawgz | Detroit Dawgz (det) | | | | |
| 19 | Fighting Skunks | Fighting Skunks (fig) | | | | |
| 20 | Crawdads | Crawdads | | | | |
